Private 5G is scaling, but Wi-Fi isn’t going anywhere

Devices, CBRS support and carrier approvals still hold back private 5G
In sum – what to know:
- Layered, not replaced – Panelists described private 5G as an extension of existing Wi-Fi and wired networks, with coverage and fewer roaming disruptions driving business cases.
- Brownfield integration – Router-based designs and matching VLANs, IP plans and network slices let enterprises add 5G without replacing working equipment.
- Barriers to scale – Thin device support, n48 and firmware gaps, expensive modules and carrier approvals that can take a year are still holding back deployments.
Private 5G is moving beyond pilots and into requests for proposals, industrial campuses and production deployments, but adoption remains uneven. Some enterprises are adding cellular connectivity to factories and warehouses that already run on Wi-Fi and wired networks. Others are still waiting on devices, band support or a business case that holds up.
Those constraints ran through a panel at the RCR Wireless Industrial Wireless Forum featuring representatives from Celona, Druid Software, the Wireless Broadband Alliance and Lufthansa Cargo. The panelists discussed private 5G as a layer on top of networks already in place, with Wi-Fi and wired operational technology expected to remain. Business cases followed the same pattern. Coverage, fewer roaming disruptions and less cabling came up more often than automation projects.
Private 5G is commercializing without replacing Wi-Fi
Wireless Broadband Alliance CTO Bruno Tomas said more of the organization’s members are issuing requests for proposals and deploying private networks across industrial campuses. Those projects commonly combine private cellular and Wi-Fi, with wired systems still connecting equipment. Some deployments may also incorporate non-terrestrial networks, or NTN, which use satellites to reach places ground towers can’t.
Capital expenditure is shaping those choices, and Tomas called it “a very important consideration.” He said sites built around supervisory control and data acquisition systems, commonly known as SCADA, need investments in wireless that improve workforce efficiency or support changes to the production line. Manufacturing, retail and logistics operations that already have wireless are looking at automation, real-time inventory and physical AI, meaning software that helps machines perceive and act in the physical world. Both groups have reasons to preserve infrastructure that already works rather than paying for a network replacement.
The management model varies just as much as the use case. Puneet Shetty, who leads product and field engineering at Celona, said enterprises with their own IT and operational technology teams may want to run private 5G themselves, while others expect systems integrators to handle day-to-day operations. Celona’s Orion platform grew out of one design question, Shetty said.
“One of the biggest driving principles for our architecture is, can a team that today operates Wi-Fi networks, whether it’s the partner of Celona or whether it’s the end customer, the team that operates their Wi-Fi infrastructure, their existing LAN infrastructure, can they treat private 5G as an extension of that?”
Druid Software takes another approach with its Remus core, which can be tailored and licensed for verticals with their own requirements. In either case, vendors have to support both models, with deployments managed in-house or by partners.
Lufthansa Cargo offered a counterweight to the vendor claims. Mario Schwarz, the company’s U.S. operations production manager for technology and infrastructure, said its main requirement was coverage across warehouses without cell roaming. Roaming is the handoff between wireless coverage areas, and handoffs can disrupt mobile work. Years of expanding and rearranging Wi-Fi access points had left the company managing installations with ever more access points, while a single cell could cover far more ground with fewer roaming boundaries.
Private 4G can address that same mobility requirement, and Schwarz said Lufthansa Cargo’s private network can operate on either 4G or 5G. The newer generation opens a path to more 5G capabilities, but Schwarz said it wasn’t the original justification for the project.
“This was not fancy AI. Even this is an important use case for us as well, but the baseline was simply connectivity.”
Wi-Fi also remains in place. Schwarz framed private cellular as an extension of the network the company already has, not an attempt to displace it.
The warehouse applications reflect that emphasis on connectivity. Lufthansa Cargo uses its tracking software with barcode and QR code scanners to follow pallets through loading and unloading. The codes can include cargo weight and dimensions, feeding automatically generated load sheets that tell crews how to distribute cargo for an aircraft’s weight and balance. Federal Aviation Administration rules still require a qualified person to perform that work, so more automation depends on regulatory approval as well as network capability.
Brownfield integration favors mirroring existing networks
On a brownfield site, where equipment and networks are already installed, Druid Software’s David O’Byrne said the priority is to build on what already exists.
“The key thing when you’re going for a brownfield implementation is as much as possible to reflect and extend the existing infrastructure, rather than going for a complete replacement.”
One method is to reproduce the traffic groups that network teams have already established through VLANs, short for virtual local area networks. These can separate visitors, employees, maintenance teams and control systems even when they share the same hardware.
Private 5G network slicing can create matching partitions for cellular devices. Internet Protocol addressing plans already in use can also extend into the private 5G core. That gives network teams a way to group and manage traffic across Wi-Fi and cellular endpoints instead of forcing them to administer cellular as its own system.
The same principle applies to factory equipment. O’Byrne described using 5G routers to collect traffic from wired switches, sensors and valves nearby before carrying it back to SCADA and operations support systems. Wired links can remain in place around each router, eliminating long cable runs across a factory. Programmable logic controllers, the computers that operate machinery, therefore don’t all need their own 5G modems.
That approach addresses an economic problem. Native 5G modules remain considerably more expensive than wired or Wi-Fi alternatives, making a one-for-one device replacement difficult to justify. Wi-Fi is still easier to use with endpoints already deployed, while private cellular offers mobile coverage across wider areas. Compared with running fiber across a facility, a router-based design preserves wired links where they’re cheap and uses wireless where cabling becomes expensive.
There are also workarounds for equipment that predates digital networking. O’Byrne described cameras pointed at analog gauges on valves, allowing readings to be transmitted wirelessly to a management center. Lufthansa Cargo has similarly had to bridge LoRa sensors, which use radio links for small amounts of data, and Wi-Fi devices into its private 5G backbone. Those bridges add hardware to monitor and manage, but they can be preferable to replacing sensors that still work.
O’Byrne expects these projects to account for much of industrial private 5G growth in Europe and the U.S. That makes integration skill central to deployment. A capable radio network won’t get very far if it requires an enterprise to discard decades of machinery that still works.
Device maturity and CBRS still constrain scale
Device availability is improving, particularly for handhelds and connected-worker equipment, but support built into machinery remains thinner. Automated guided vehicles, which follow set routes, and autonomous mobile robots, which navigate more independently, still commonly connect through industrial mobile routers. Shetty said some manufacturers are beginning to integrate 5G modules directly, but routers remain how many robots, sensors and industrial IoT devices connect.
In the U.S., Citizens Broadband Radio Service adds a complication. CBRS allows organizations to use shared spectrum, with many deployments relying on the 3.5GHz band known as n48. Schwarz said vendor claims often fall apart once the questions get specific.
“A lot of vendors are advertising their 5G-ready devices, but they are not ready on Band N48. This is a thing that we, or I, experience on a daily basis.”
Lufthansa Cargo encountered that problem while seeking sensors that work, leaving it to assemble bridges between equipment that otherwise can’t talk.
Hardware support for n48 doesn’t necessarily settle the matter. Shetty said some devices also lack firmware support for the public land mobile network and network identifiers that tell them how to join a private network. A device can therefore have the radio hardware and still require a firmware change before it works on a customer’s deployment.
Timing creates another barrier. An enterprise may be ready to replace its network while remaining several years away from refreshing devices it has already purchased. If those endpoints don’t support private 5G, the customer may postpone the project, settle for a smaller deployment or continue living with the coverage problem. Industrial equipment operates on longer cycles than phones or networking gear, with O’Byrne noting lifespans ranging from roughly 20 years to as long as 50 years in some factories. Standards can be written much faster than that equipment can be replaced, and O’Byrne said the industry has to adjust its pace.
“We are working at the speed of industry now, not the speed of telecoms, and certainly not the speed of software.”
Cost compounds the delay. Adding a router to every controller or machine can become prohibitively expensive, even when the network case still holds up. Reduced Capability 5G, or RedCap, is intended to address that gap with simpler, cheaper and lower-power devices. Shetty described a customer connecting controllers over private 5G that is holding out for RedCap pricing.
“They are waiting for this nirvana that RedCap will come and it’ll reduce the cost of the devices by half or maybe a third. But that has not yet happened. So we are starting to see RedCap devices show up. The price improvements that were expected are not yet there.”
More deployments would give chipset and device vendors a market with real volume, though that scale still has to be built.
Automation will place more demands on the network. Connectivity alone may be enough to keep a tablet working as an employee walks around a site, but other deployments need voice service, predictable data delivery or latency below one millisecond. Time-sensitive networking, a group of standards designed to make data delivery deterministic, could become important as autonomous machines work more closely with people. Those requirements are considerably harder to satisfy than simply covering a warehouse.
The Wireless Broadband Alliance is trying to reduce some of the surrounding integration work through what Tomas called converged value blueprints. The effort covers security, identity, policy, roaming and service continuity across Wi-Fi, private 5G and connected devices. Tomas said the length of carrier approvals surprised him more than anything else this year.
“One of the things that surprised me the most during this year is that the time frame to approve a project to integrate with carriers, so they have roaming in the venue, can take up to one year. So imagine how can we really achieve scale if we don’t have pre-approved designs?”
Private 5G’s path to scale therefore depends on more than radio performance. Affordable RedCap devices, dependable n48 and firmware support, and faster carrier approvals all remain unresolved. Until those pieces improve, industrial routers, Wi-Fi and wired equipment will continue doing much of the work inside private 5G deployments.
Table of Contents
Comments are closed.